Lead platforms compared

Thumbtack vs Angi for contractors: how each one charges, and a third option.

Both platforms sell you access to homeowners who are also talking to other contractors. They differ in how you pay and how much control you get. Here is the comparison, without a referral link to either.

Side by side

Thumbtack, Angi and your own ads

ThumbtackAngiYour own ads (what we run)
How you payPer lead, when a new customer contacts you. No sign-up or subscription fee.Per lead. Annual subscribers get a monthly lead budget billed monthly; others are billed weekly.Ad spend to Google or Meta, plus a flat management fee.
Lead priceVaries by job size and location. You set preferences and a budget.Varies by work type, location and demand.Set by auction. Typically $40–$300 per call depending on trade.
Who else gets the leadCustomers can compare and contact several pros.Homeowner chooses the pros; up to five per request.Nobody. The homeowner called your number.
CommitmentNone.Depends on the program; subscriptions are annual.90-day build, then month-to-month with us.
What you keep if you stopYour reviews on Thumbtack.Your reviews on Angi.The ad accounts, landing pages, call history and Google reviews.
Time to first leadDays.Days.One to two weeks.

Platform details were checked in November 2026 against the companies' own help pages and published guides. Both platforms change their programs often. Confirm current terms on angi.com and thumbtack.com before you sign up.

Thumbtack

How Thumbtack works for pros

You create a profile, choose the job types and areas you want, and set a weekly budget. There is no membership fee. You are charged when a new customer contacts you through the platform, whether or not you win the job.

Good fit for: new businesses with no reviews elsewhere, trades with small fast jobs (handyman, cleaning, junk removal, TV mounting), and filling gaps in the schedule.

Watch for: paying for contacts that never reply, and customers who messaged four pros with the same question. Speed of reply decides most jobs.

Angi

How Angi works for pros

Angi matches homeowner requests with pros in its network. Under its current model the homeowner picks which pros receive the request, with up to five per request according to Angi. Lead prices vary by work type, location and demand, and billing depends on whether you hold an annual subscription.

Good fit for: established companies with a sales process fast enough to win a contested lead, in markets where Angi has heavy homeowner traffic.

Watch for: the contract terms. Read how the monthly budget works, what happens if you go over it, and what it takes to cancel.

The third option

Running your own ads instead

On both platforms you are renting someone else's audience. When you advertise directly on Google or Meta, the homeowner searches, sees your company, and calls your number. No other contractor receives that lead, and the reviews you earn build your own Google profile.

The trade-off is setup time and a minimum budget of about $1,000 a month in ad spend. For most contractors past their first year, the cost per booked job ends up lower. Our Google Ads and Local Services Ads pages show how each works.

How to decide

Compare on cost per booked job, not cost per lead

An illustration with round numbers. Yours will differ; the method is what matters.

SourceCost per leadClose rateCost per booked job
Lead platform, contested lead$4510%$450
Your own search ad, exclusive call$11035%$314

Example figures for illustration only. Track your own leads and booked jobs by source for 60 days and run the same sum.

Questions contractors ask

Thumbtack vs Angi questions

Is Thumbtack or Angi better for contractors?

It depends on the trade and the market. Thumbtack has no subscription and gives you more control over which jobs you pay for. Angi has more homeowner traffic in many markets and offers annual subscriptions with a monthly lead budget. Many contractors test both for 60 days and keep whichever produces the lower cost per booked job.

Are Thumbtack leads exclusive?

Not necessarily. Customers on Thumbtack can compare several pros and choose whom to contact. Thumbtack says it limits competition but does not publish a cap.

Are Angi leads shared?

They can be. Angi moved to a model where the homeowner chooses which pros receive the request, and says a request can be matched with no more than five pros. The number varies by lead type and location.

Is HomeAdvisor the same as Angi?

HomeAdvisor is owned by Angi Inc. Contractors who used HomeAdvisor Pro are now served under Angi's programs.

What is the alternative to both?

Running your own advertising on Google and Meta, where the homeowner contacts your company directly and nobody else receives the lead. It takes longer to set up and you own the accounts.

See what exclusive leads would cost in your market

The audit gives you a cost per lead for your trade and zip code, so you can compare it with what the platforms charge you now.

Get my free market audit
Call (877) 934-9998 Free audit