The quick comparison
If you searched for CraftJack, start here: CraftJack was folded into Angi. Its help center says CraftJack lead volume stopped on February 29, access to its Lead Manager and mobile app ended on March 31, and pros who wanted to keep buying leads were moved to Angi Leads accounts. The craftjack.com address now forwards to Angi's pro sign-up page.
That leaves three smaller lead sellers worth knowing. They charge in three different ways, and only one of them publishes a price.
| CraftJack | Porch | Bark | Modernize | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Status | Merged into Angi | Active | Active | Active |
| How you pay | Now through an Angi Leads account | Buy leads one at a time, set a monthly budget for automatic leads, or both | Buy credits; each lead costs a set number of credits to respond to | Custom program; per-lead cost set by a dynamic pricing model |
| Published price | None. CraftJack's notice says Angi's lead prices tend to be slightly higher than CraftJack's were | None | $2.35 per credit in the US, as of November 2026; credits per lead vary | None |
| Do you choose each lead? | See Angi | Yes when buying one at a time; no on a monthly budget | Yes. The credit cost shows before you respond | No. Leads are routed by project type, location and campaign settings |
| Shared or exclusive | Angi says no more than five pros per request | Not stated on the pro page | Not stated in the articles we read | Not stated on the leads page |
| Best suited to | See Angi | Small shops that want to test with a few leads | Small, quick-decision service jobs | Established replacement and remodeling companies with a sales team |
"Not stated" means the company's own page did not say when we checked in November 2026. In each case, ask before you buy.
CraftJack: now part of Angi
CraftJack sold home-improvement leads to contractors as a separate brand. Its closing notice says Angi acquired CraftJack and that the two networks would no longer be separate. Contractors who already had Angi accounts were told to move their CraftJack spend to Angi. Contractors who did not were told to open an Angi Leads account, which requires a background check and license verification.
If you were a CraftJack customer, the things to know now are how Angi's leads and billing work. Those are covered in Angi Pro, Angi Leads and Angi Ads, and the math for deciding whether to stay is on Is Angi worth it?
Porch leads
Porch is a home services marketplace where homeowners request quotes from independent pros. On the pro side, Porch says you get a profile for your credentials, reviews and projects, and you set work preferences: how far you will travel and which project types you want. Leads can arrive by email, text or direct phone call.
Porch describes three ways to pay. You can buy leads individually, set a monthly budget for automatic lead delivery, or combine the two. It also runs a Vetted Pro program. Porch says Vetted Pros get a profile badge, 5 percent back on leads bought on demand, and a Connection Guarantee: if you follow the outreach requirements and still cannot connect with the homeowner, you receive lead credits automatically.
Porch does not publish lead prices. What to ask:
- The lead price for each of your project types in your zip codes.
- How many other pros receive the same lead.
- The exact outreach steps required for the Connection Guarantee, and how the credit is applied.
- Whether a monthly budget can be paused or lowered at any time.
Suits: a small shop that wants to buy ten leads by hand, see what they are like, and only then set a budget.
Bark leads
Bark covers many kinds of services, home trades among them. A customer posts a request and professionals respond with quotes. Bark's site says professionals are only given the customer's details once they have sent a quote. The currency is the credit.
Bark's help center lists the current US credit price as $2.35 per credit, as of November 2026, and says rates vary by country and package, with larger packs lowering the cost per credit. Each lead has a credit cost that depends on the service and the size of the job. Bark says the credit cost is always visible on the lead before you respond.
The lead price is simple multiplication. These are examples of the sum. They are not Bark's prices for any service.
| Credits to respond | Cost at $2.35 per credit |
|---|---|
| 5 | $11.75 |
| 10 | $23.50 |
| 20 | $47.00 |
Three rules from Bark's help center change how you should buy:
- Credits bought from November 1, 2025 expire three months after purchase.
- Unused credits cannot be refunded.
- Auto top-up, if switched on, buys more credits when your balance runs low.
Bark also sells credit subscriptions, paid weekly or monthly, at a lower cost per credit. They are arranged through its Customer Success Team, can run up to 12 months, and continue after that unless you cancel. Bark says you can cancel at any time, and that cancelling within the first three months may make you ineligible for future subscriptions.
With a three-month expiry and no refunds on unused credits, a large pack is a bet that you will use it. Start small, leave auto top-up off, and track booked jobs per credit spent.
Suits: small, quick-decision jobs where you can answer a request within minutes and send a clear price.
Modernize leads
Modernize is built for larger home-improvement companies. Its site says it generates form-fill leads from homeowners on Modernize.com and partner sites across more than 20 trades, including roofing, HVAC, windows, solar, plumbing, bath and kitchen remodeling, walk-in tubs and tree services. Leads are routed by project type, location and campaign settings and delivered instantly to your CRM or lead app.
There is no public price list. Modernize says its "dynamic pricing model aligns lead cost with performance and quality signals," and that it custom builds a program based on your annual revenue. The sign-up form asks which revenue band you fall in, from under $500,000 to over $100 million. It also asks partners to share set rate, win rate and order value so campaigns can be adjusted.
The leads page does not say how many contractors receive each lead, what the minimum spend is, or how bad leads are handled. Those are the first three questions for the sales call. Also ask whether calls are sold as a separate product, since the site lists one.
Suits: replacement and remodeling companies with a call center or a dedicated person to work web leads, a CRM, and tickets large enough to absorb a contested lead. A two-truck repair shop is unlikely to be the customer the program is built around.
How to compare any of them on your own numbers
- Pick one seller and set a fixed test budget. For most small shops $500 to $1,000 is enough to learn something.
- Log every lead: price, reached or not, quoted or not, won or lost, job value.
- After 60 days, divide total spend by booked jobs.
- Divide that by your average job value. Under 10 to 15 percent, keep it. Over that, stop or renegotiate.
- Run the same sum for one exclusive source over the same period.
An example with made-up figures: 30 leads at $35 is $1,050. Reach 17, book 3 jobs averaging $2,400. Cost per booked job is $350, or 14.6 percent of the ticket. One fewer job and it is 21.9 percent.
Where these fit among your options
All of these sell you a homeowner's contact details, usually alongside other contractors. The other route is advertising you own, where the homeowner calls your number and nobody else gets the lead. Our HomeAdvisor alternatives page lists those options, and cost per lead by trade gives typical ranges to hold a quote against. For the other platforms, see Networx leads review and Thumbtack vs Angi.
Sources
- CraftJack Help, CraftJack is moving to Angi: lead stop and access end dates, move to Angi Leads, note on Angi lead prices.
- Angi Help, Leads FAQ: no more than five pros per request.
- Porch, pro page: profile, work preferences, ways to buy leads, Vetted Pro perks and Connection Guarantee.
- Bark Help, What is a credit and how much does it cost: $2.35 per credit, credit cost shown before responding, expiry, no refunds on unused credits, auto top-up.
- Bark Help, Credit Pack Subscriptions: subscription terms and cancellation.
- Bark Help, Why some leads cost more credits: credit cost depends on service and job size.
- Bark, home page: customer details released once a professional sends a quote.
- Modernize, leads for pros: form-fill leads, routing, dynamic pricing, custom programs by revenue, trades covered.
Checked November 2026. Programs and prices change; confirm on the company's own site.
