Follow-up and operations

Answering Services and AI Receptionists for Contractors Compared

From the prices companies publish, a live answering service works out to roughly $5 to $11 per three-minute call and an AI receptionist to between 25 cents and $3. Live agents handle upset callers and odd requests better. AI handles volume, nights and simple booking for far less.

The short answer on an answering service for contractors

An answering service for contractors puts a person or a piece of software on your phone when you cannot pick up. Both are far cheaper than a missed job. Pick a live service if your calls are emotional, complicated or high ticket, such as a flooded basement or a roof claim. Pick an AI receptionist if most of your calls are "do you service my area, what does it cost, when can you come" and you need every call answered at 2am without paying per minute at live rates.

Plenty of shops use both: staff during the day, AI or a live service for overflow and after hours. Whatever you choose, judge it on booked jobs per 100 calls, and listen to the recordings.

How a live answering service works and what it costs

You forward your line, all the time or only when you do not answer. A receptionist picks up with your greeting, follows your script, takes a message or books the job, and can transfer true emergencies to your on-call phone. Most bill by the minute or by the call. These are published prices from each company's own pricing page as of November 2026.

Live servicePublished plansHow it bills
Ruby50 minutes for $250 a month, 100 for $395, 200 for $720, 500 for $1,725Per receptionist minute. 24/7 live answering and Spanish call handling listed. The page says there are no setup fees. Overage rates are not listed on the page.
PATLivePay as you go at $49 a month plus $2.99 a minute. 100 minutes for $189, 200 for $349, 300 for $479, 500 for $759Per minute, with extra minutes from $2.09 down to $1.79 on those plans. Month to month. 24/7, US-based receptionists, emergency dispatch listed.
Smith.ai Virtual ReceptionistsStarter: 30 calls for $300 a month. Basic: 90 calls for $810. Pro: 300 calls for $2,100Per call. Extra calls $11.50, $10.50 and $8.50 by plan. Appointment booking is listed as a $1.50 per-call add-on. The page says spam calls are not charged.

How an AI receptionist works and what it costs

An AI receptionist is software that answers in a natural voice, asks your intake questions, answers common questions from the information you give it, books or takes a message, and texts you a summary. It answers every call at once, so nobody gets a busy signal during a storm or a heat wave.

AI receptionistPublished plansHow it bills
Smith.ai AI ReceptionistFree plan with 25 calls a month. Pro from $150 a month with 75, 150 or 300-call tiers. Enterprise from $500Per call. Extra calls listed at $3.00 on Free and $2.50, $2.30 or $2.17 on Pro tiers.
GoodcallStarter $79 a month, Growth $129, Scale $299Per unique caller per month: 100, 500 and 2,000 included. The page says it never meters minutes.
RosieProfessional $49 a month, Scale $149, Growth $299Per minute: 250, 1,000 and 2,000 minutes included. Calendar booking and live transfers start on Scale. English and Spanish listed.
Jobber AI Receptionist$29 a month as an add-on, included in Jobber's Plus planFlat add-on. Requires Jobber. Answers calls and texts and can book visits into your Jobber schedule.
Housecall Pro CSR AINo price on the product pageRequires a Housecall Pro account. Answers calls and chats and books jobs. Ask for the monthly price and any per-call charges.

If you already run Jobber or Housecall Pro, try the built-in option first, because it books straight into your schedule. Our Jobber vs Housecall Pro comparison covers the rest of each product.

Cost per call, side by side

To compare per-minute and per-call pricing, assume a three-minute call. That is an example figure. Time your own calls for a week and redo the math.

OptionMath from published priceCost per 3-minute call
Ruby, 200-minute plan$720 / 200 minutes = $3.60 a minuteAbout $10.80
Smith.ai live, Basic$810 / 90 calls$9.00
PATLive, 300-minute plan$479 / 300 minutes = $1.60 a minuteAbout $4.80
Smith.ai AI ReceptionistListed per-call rates of $2.17 to $3.00About $2 to $3
Rosie, Scale$149 / 1,000 minutes = 15 cents a minuteAbout 45 cents
Goodcall, Growth$129 / 500 unique callersAbout 26 cents per caller

These figures assume you use the whole plan. If you buy 200 minutes and use 80, your real cost per call more than doubles. Size the plan from your call log.

Compare against the job

If a booked service call is worth $300 to you, the gap between a $1 call and a $10 call matters far less than whether the caller booked. Grade on bookings first, price second.

Where live services fail

  • They do not know your trade. A shared receptionist answers for dentists and law firms too. Without a tight script they cannot tell a no-heat call from a filter question.
  • Message taking instead of booking. If the service only takes a name and number, you still have to win the callback race. Insist on booking into your calendar.
  • Minute creep. Long scripts and hold time eat the plan. Read the first two invoices line by line.
  • Peak hours. When a storm hits your town, call volume jumps for you and for every other local client of that service.

Where AI receptionists fail

  • Upset or confused callers. A homeowner with water coming through the ceiling may hang up on a machine. Set urgent keywords to transfer straight to a person.
  • Anything off script. Warranty disputes, a neighbor's complaint, a commercial bid. The AI should take a message and hand off, and you should test that it does.
  • Wrong answers stated with confidence. If you never told it your service area or your diagnostic fee, it may guess or dodge. Feed it your towns, hours, fees and what you do not do.
  • Bad audio. Speakerphones, accents, wind and a bad cell signal trip up speech recognition more than they trip up a person.
  • Disclosure. Decide whether the greeting says the caller is talking to an AI assistant, and check your state's rules on call recording and automated calls with your attorney.

How to choose for your shop

  1. Count your misses. Pull 30 days of call logs. Count missed calls by hour and day. Call tracking software makes this a quick report.
  2. Sort your calls. Listen to 20 recordings. Mark each as simple, emergency or complicated.
  3. Match the tool. Mostly simple calls: AI. Many emergencies or high-ticket estimates: live, or AI with fast transfer to your on-call tech.
  4. Write the script. Greeting, service area, five intake questions, what counts as an emergency, who gets the transfer, and what to say about price.
  5. Run a two-week test. Forward after-hours calls only. Listen to every call. Count calls answered, jobs booked and callers who hung up.
  6. Add a safety net. Keep missed call text back on for anything that still slips through.

Notes for HVAC and plumbing shops

An HVAC answering service has to handle two very different days: a mild Tuesday in October and the first 95-degree afternoon in June. Ask any provider how they handle a tripling of calls in one day. For no-heat, no-cooling and active leak calls, set a rule that the call transfers to your on-call tech within the first minute. Give the service your maintenance member list so members get the priority you promised them.

Answer rate matters most when you pay for the call. With Local Services Ads you pay per lead, and a typical exclusive HVAC repair lead in Ohio markets runs $60 to $180. Letting those ring out is the most expensive mistake on this page. Our HVAC marketing plan and speed to lead guide cover the rest of the follow-up. LeadGen records and tracks calls on the campaigns we manage, and the free market audit shows how many calls your market produces.

Sources

Checked November 2026. Programs and prices change; confirm on the company's own site.

FAQ

Questions

How much does an answering service cost per month?

Published live plans in November 2026 start around $99 to $300 a month for 30 to 50 calls or minutes and climb with volume. AI receptionist plans we checked start between $29 and $150 a month.

Can an AI receptionist book jobs into my calendar?

Many can. Check the plan level, because some products reserve calendar booking and live transfers for higher tiers.

Will callers know they are talking to AI?

Often yes, and some products let you choose whether the greeting says so. Being upfront usually goes over better than a caller figuring it out midway.

Should I forward all calls or only missed calls?

Start with missed and after-hours calls. Your own staff know the work and usually book better when they can answer, and you keep the bill down.

Do answering services charge for spam calls?

It depends on the provider. Smith.ai's page says it does not charge for spam. Ask each provider how spam and wrong numbers are billed.

Find out what a lead should cost in your zip code

The audit takes us a day. You'll get competitor spend, likely cost per lead and a plain recommendation, even if that recommendation is "don't run ads yet."

Get my free market audit
Call (877) 934-9998 Free audit